An Arkansas dad accused of killing a man charged with sexually abusing his teenage daughter has scored a massive courtroom victory ... because he's off the hook in his murder case.

A judge on Thursday tossed the second-degree murder charge against Aaron Spencer, the Arkansas father who became a national headline after launching a campaign for county sheriff while awaiting trial.

Play video content Video 4

Aaron Spencer Announces Run for Lonoke County Sheriff

Video 5

Video 6

0 seconds of 1 minute, 8 seconds Volume 90%

Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts

Keyboard Shortcuts Enabled Disabled

Shortcuts Open/Close/ or ?

Play/Pause SPACE

Increase Volume↑

Decrease Volume↓

Seek Forward→

Seek Backward←

Captions On/Off c

Fullscreen/Exit Fullscreen f

Mute/Unmute m

Decrease Caption Size-

Increase Caption Size+ or =

Seek %0-9

Next Up

L.A. County Sheriff -- We Got Room for Lindsay in Jail

00:47

Subtitle Settings

Off English

Font Color

White

Font Opacity

100%

Font Size

100%

Font Family

Arial

Character Edge

None

Edge Color

Black

Background Color

Black

Background Opacity

75%

Window Color

Black

Window Opacity

Reset

White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan

100%75%50%25%

200%175%150%125%100%75%50%

Arial Courier Georgia Impact Lucida Console Tahoma Times New Roman Trebuchet MS Verdana

None Raised Depressed Uniform Drop Shadow

White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan

100%75%50%25%0%

White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan

100%75%50%25%0%

Auto 360p (300 kbps)720p (1253 kbps)720p (984 kbps)480p (663 kbps)360p (300 kbps)240p (179 kbps)240p (162 kbps)

Live

00:00

01:08

BUILD A SAFER COUNTY

Video: Aaron Spencer Announces Run for Lonoke County Sheriff

Facebook/Aaron Spencer for Lonoke County Sheriff

The ruling stems from a lengthy fight over missing evidence. Spencer's attorneys argued investigators lost key materials during the case ... and the judge ultimately decided misconduct by law enforcement "was so egregious that dismissal of this case is warranted."

As TMZ previously reported, Spencer was accused of fatally shooting Michael Foslerin October 2024, when Fosler was facing dozens of child sex crime charges involving Spencer's teenage daughter. Fosler was out on bond at the time of the shooting.

Heather Spencer/Facebook

Spencer pleaded not guilty and maintained he was trying to protect his child.

The case drew national attention not only because of the allegations against Fosler, but because Spencer later announced he was running for sheriff in Lonoke County while still facing the murder charge. Despite the pending case, he won the Republican primary earlier this year.

Spencer spent nearly two years fighting the allegation ... and was set to go to trial June 22.

#### Karen Read Sues 'Biased and Corrupt' Cops, Claims Officers Regularly Used Slurs

#### Karmelo Anthony Trial Begins With Debate Over Who Started Confrontation

#### Florida Realtor, Ex-Husband and Young Daughters Dead in Apparent Murder-Suicide

#### Nicole Brown Simpson's Sister Says O.J.'s No. 32 Jersey Should Be Abolished

Aaron Spencer Current Events Legal News

Read our community guidelines for comments on TMZ

MORE FOR YOU

[Edema Is Not From Salty Food. Meet The Real Enemy Of Swollen Legs RejuvaCare - Sponsored Sponsored](https://ad.rejuvacare.com/575625a1-6abc-4d72-a853-fbc78ade189c "Edema Is Not From Salty Food. Meet The Real Enemy Of Swollen Legs")

Undo

[Heart Surgeon: This Food Can Turn You Into A Fat Burning Machine Gundry MD - Sponsored Sponsored Learn More](https://lander.thehealthyfat.com/pl260513a_ap "Heart Surgeon: This Food Can Turn You Into A Fat Burning Machine")

Undo

[Diabetic Neuropathy Has Been Linked to This Common Drink Daily. Do You Drink It?Objetivo de marketing - Sponsored Sponsored Learn More](https://steadylivingguide.online/presell-1 "Diabetic Neuropathy Has Been Linked to This Common Drink Daily. Do You Drink It?")

Undo

[Why Your Sciatic Nerve Won't Heal (What Most Doctors Miss)RejuvaCare - Sponsored Sponsored](https://ad.rejuvacare.com/960ab3ea-388b-432b-b0f2-f026349273f6 "Why Your Sciatic Nerve Won't Heal (What Most Doctors Miss)")

Undo

[Iowa Is Cracking Down On Toxic Cookware — Here's The Safe Alternative Kitchen-Experts - Sponsored Sponsored Learn More](https://trkv.plateful.co/4e35fdf4-d851-443b-8422-ae497d34bc4f "Iowa Is Cracking Down On Toxic Cookware — Here's The Safe Alternative")

Undo

[She Mixed Gelatin With This - Now She Can't Stop Losing Weight arcticbloomjournal - Sponsored Sponsored](https://www.arcticbloomjournal.live/8a7o2889xw "She Mixed Gelatin With This - Now She Can't Stop Losing Weight")

Undo

[A Gelatin 1/3 Cup Lemon Water - In Less Than A Month (Watch)goldenridgecourier - Sponsored Sponsored](https://www.goldenridgecourier.live/8vgbsuvq0p "A Gelatin 1/3 Cup Lemon Water - In Less Than A Month (Watch)")

Undo

[When Neuropathy Hits, Try This Immediately (It's Brilliant!)The Healthier Way - Sponsored Sponsored Learn More](https://careforurhealthdaily.com/neuro-daily-care "When Neuropathy Hits, Try This Immediately (It's Brilliant!)")

Undo

ABOUT TMZ

CONTACT TMZ

Yes! Send me email updates and offers from TMZ and its Affiliates. By subscribing, I agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

Subscribe to TMZ newsletter Subscribe

Murder Case Against Arkansas Sheriff Candidate Aaron Spencer Dismissed

Murder Case Against Arkansas Sheriff Candidate Aaron Spencer Dismissed

Shows

Download The App

Murder Case Against Arkansas Sheriff Candidate Aaron Spencer Dismissed

Arkansas Dad Accused of Murder Charges Dismissed As He Runs For Sheriff

Related articles

Most Popular

ABOUT TMZ

CONTACT TMZ

SUBSCRIBE

FOLLOW

TMZ APPS

We Care About Your Privacy

How and why we process data